Raj Chaupalराज चौपाल

Encyclopedia · Constitution · Article 102(1)(a)

Office of Profit, explained लाभ का पद

An MP or MLA can lose their seat for holding a post under the government that brings benefits.

An 'office of profit' means a post under the Central or a state government that brings a salary, allowances or other benefits. The Constitution wants MPs and MLAs to keep a watch on the government, not to become obliged to it by taking benefits from it.

Article 102(1)(a) for MPs and Article 191(1)(a) for MLAs say that a person holding such a post is disqualified from being a member, unless Parliament or the state legislature exempts that post by law. At the Central level, this exemption is given in the Parliament (Prevention of Disqualification) Act, 1959. In the case of an MP, the final decision is taken by the President on the opinion of the Election Commission (Article 103).

The Constitution does not define 'office of profit', so its meaning has been worked out through court judgments. That is why this issue has suddenly become a major problem for leaders of different parties.

Law: Parliament (Prevention of Disqualification) Act, 1959

A real example: In 2006, Rajya Sabha MP Jaya Bachchan's membership was cancelled because she held the post of chairperson of the Uttar Pradesh Film Development Council. In the same year, Sonia Gandhi resigned from the Lok Sabha amid the controversy over her chairing the National Advisory Council, and won again by contesting the by-election from Rae Bareli.
Did you know? The Constitution does not define 'office of profit'; its meaning has been settled by the courts through their judgments.

Frequently asked questions

Is the post of a minister an 'office of profit'?

No. The Constitution itself says that being a minister of the Union or of a state shall not be considered an office of profit.

How can a post be protected from being treated as an office of profit?

Parliament or the state legislature can exempt that post from disqualification by law; for the Centre, this list is in the 1959 Act.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Constitution of India: Legislative Department, Government of India
  2. India Code: official repository of central laws