Raj Chaupalराज चौपाल

Encyclopedia · Constitution

Anti-Defection Law (Tenth Schedule), explained दल-बदल कानून (दसवीं अनुसूची)

Under the anti-defection law, an MP or MLA who leaves their party or defies the whip can lose their seat.

If an MP or MLA, after winning an election, leaves their party and moves to another party, it is called defection. To stop this, the 52nd Constitutional Amendment was brought in 1985 and the Tenth Schedule was added to the Constitution.

A member can lose their seat in four situations: the member voluntarily gives up party membership; votes against the party whip or abstains; an independent member joins a party after the election; or a nominated member joins a party after six months. If two-thirds of the members of a legislature party agree to a merger with another party, the law does not apply to them. The Speaker or Chairman decides.

The 91st Amendment of 2003 removed the exemption for a 'split' by one-third of the members. In the Kihoto Hollohan case (1992), the Supreme Court upheld the law, but also said that the Speaker's decision can be reviewed by the courts.

Law: Tenth Schedule of the Constitution (52nd Amendment, 1985)

A real example: In 1967, Haryana MLA Gaya Lal's repeated switching of parties gave rise to the phrase 'Aaya Ram Gaya Ram'. Incidents like this later laid the ground for the anti-defection law. Full story
Did you know? The Tenth Schedule talks less about 'defection' and more about 'disqualification': it is not a punishment but a rule for ending membership.

Frequently asked questions

Can an independent MLA later join a party?

No. If a member elected as an independent joins a party after the election, they can lose their seat.

Is there a fixed time within which the Speaker must decide?

The Tenth Schedule does not lay down any time limit. The Supreme Court has said in some cases that the decision should be made within a reasonable time.

Related terms

Sources

  1. Constitution of India: Legislative Department, Government of India
  2. Supreme Court of India